Invisible Diaries
It is by now widely accepted that no independent witnesses were shown manuscript (handwritten) diaries before Casement’s death. This has been reluctantly confirmed by Jeffrey Dudgeon although he insists this fact does not cast doubt on the material existence of manuscript diaries in 1916. However, this conflicts with his earlier published opinion which conceded they might be forgeries. This unsatisfactory situation provokes the following question: since independent persons were not shown manuscript diaries for whatever reasons, it is valid to ask who was shown manuscript diaries in 1916? Can they be named? If so, these would mostly be state officials who were shown manuscript diaries by the police and intelligence agents; indeed their official status would entitle them to personally witness the documents.
The question therefore is: Who did see manuscript diaries in 1916? What follows is the answer.
Here we owe to Jeffrey Dudgeon a very interesting point; he reveals in the November IPR that by 18th July, 1916, none of the British Cabinet of 22 ministers had been shown manuscript diaries although these had allegedly been in police possession almost three months since 25th April. Referring to Blackwell’s memorandum dated 15 July, he explains “Blackwell is addressing Cabinet Ministers who will have seen typed diary versions and not the manuscripts“. This provokes the further alarming question; if the highest government officials had not seen any manuscripts either before or after the trial, how many other officials had not been shown manuscript diaries by 18 July?
Blackwell’s memo reads “Casement’s diaries and his ledger entries cover many pages of closely typed matter.” This devastating blunder has caused havoc for those adhering to authenticity. Commenting on this event, Jeff confirms by default that the Cabinet did not see manuscript diaries on that date, 18 July, just two weeks before Casement was killed. Jeff has omitted to mention that Blackwell consulted Thomson when preparing the memorandum and had incorporated his proposals and information. The document read to ministers was in fact a joint endeavour intended to overcome indecision about Casement’s fate. Indeed, Blackwell added “I see not the slightest objection to hanging Casement and afterwards giving as much publicity to the contents of his diary as decency permits …”
In the June Irish Political Review Jeff also published a list of names which he explained are cited in official documents as being “privy to either, or both, the existence of manuscript diaries and the typing of full copies or extracts therefrom.” The list includes Frank Hall of MI5, Room 40 chief Reginald Hall, police officers Quinn, McBrien, Gill, DPP Mathews and Stephenson, Ambassador Spring-Rice, civil servants Mair, Lord Newton, Butler, Campbell, Montgomery. Their names do appear in various official documents but none of these persons confirmed in those official or other documents that they had seen manuscript diaries in 1916. Indeed the two Halls left no comment about manuscript diaries; nor did any of the others. Jeff’s locution is that the names are “… recorded in different official documents…” But he does not identify who wrote the documents and in any case their appearance in the documents has no bearing on the truth or falsity of what was recorded in the documents. Jeff evades the issue by the use of “privy to”, a coy expression which has no precise meaning and at best alludes to unverified apparently confidential information which cannot be distinguished from hearsay, rumour or gossip. He is relying on the technique of expanded innuendo.
The list of those who did not see any manuscript diaries before 18 July 1916 includes the entire Asquith cabinet of some 22 or more ministers. In addition, Captain Hall, the guiding spirit of the defamatory campaign, left no material evidence claiming he had seen such diaries. Nor did Alfred Noyes working as a Foreign Office propagandist in 1916 who years later confirmed he was shown only police typescripts for a short time. Many other officials cited did not see manuscript diaries; they include the British ambassador in Washington Cecil Spring Rice who saw only unidentified photographs (since destroyed) and Captain Guy Gaunt naval attaché in Washington, the intelligence officer who received the unidentified photographs which Captain Walcott brought from Scotland Yard in July 1916. Gaunt never claimed he had seen manuscript diaries. Nor did Walcott although he received the packet of photographs in person from Thomson in his Scotland Yard office. Indeed, those photographs which were intended to convince US skeptics have never been seen since. Destruction of one’s own evidence is de facto proof of its falsity.
None of the three judges at Casement’s trial – Reading, Horridge, Avory – or the four judges at the later appeal left any evidence that they had seen manuscript diaries before, during or after the trial and appeal. Prosecutor Smith who hated Casement certainly had read the police typescripts but made no claim then or later that he had ever seen manuscript diaries. Defence barrister Sullivan who also detested Casement never claimed he had seen manuscript diaries at any time and refused to look at the typescripts offered to him. Despite their joint efforts to locate and see the alleged diaries, Casement’s three-man legal team – Duffy, Morgan and Doyle – found nothing, not even the police typescripts. Neither the Director of Public Prosecutions nor his deputy Stephenson left evidence that they had seen manuscript diaries although police documents confirm their submission of the typescripts to them.
While his defence barrister Sullivan and state prosecutor Smith loathed him, it was perhaps the cabinet legal advisor Ernley Blackwell who nurtured the most intense venom against Casement. Paradoxically, it was that intoxicating poison which caused him to issue his disastrous description of the non-existent diaries as “many pages of closely typed matter”. With these few words Blackwell inadvertently betrayed that he was yet another high-ranking official who had never seen manuscript diaries.
Jeff lists three cabinet ministers – Asquith, Grey and Smith – as being “privy to” but in his June IPR letter he confirms they did not see manuscript diaries. From this apparent contradiction we can determine that Jeff’s “privy to” is simply an insinuation to conceal that they had not actually set eyes on manuscript diaries.
In July 1916 two Harley Street alienists (psychiatrists) were consulted by the Home Office ostensibly to determine if Casement was mentally ill. This curious event might have made sense before the trial when the outcome would have had a bearing on his ability to stand trial. Doctors Craig and Smith did not see Casement in person which would normally be required for an appraisal of mental condition and certainly indispensable when the subject was a man already condemned to death. Instead of direct contact, the doctors were given the police typescripts dated 1911. This is confirmed by their report of 10 July which stated their opinion that the author of the typescripts which they described as “copies” was “undoubtedly a mentally abnormal individual,” but was not mentally ill. While the doctors were not formally state employees they were commissioned and paid by the state, therefore were acting on behalf of the Home Office. But more importantly, they joined the lengthening list of those serving the state who did not see manuscript diaries.
Gaselee, Foreign Office official librarian, was active in the defamation plot and promoted the showing of the typescripts. It was he who imposed the typescripts on Alfred Noyes whose spontaneous verbal comment was cited without his consent in a propaganda article published in the USA. Noyes writes “…the one brief paragraph… was published in America with false captions and even, as I learned years later, with additions, including the statement that I had ‘made search’ to authenticate the diary…” which he had never seen. Naturally, Gaselee himself left no evidence that he had ever set eyes on manuscript diaries.
It is perhaps fitting that the list of officials who never saw manuscript diaries should terminate with King George V’s involvement. It is certain that the monarch saw defamatory documents but their identity is unclear. Nonetheless, the decision to show documents to the monarch was certainly taken by Captain Hall who visited Windsor at 4 pm on 24 April as verified in the royal diary when he reported Casement’s arrest. However, it is not known if Hall returned in May with documents for the king. If not Hall it was probably his Room 40 colleague Lord Herschell K.C.V.O. who was a Lord-in-Waiting to the king. There is no reason to think that the king was shown anything different from the typescripts shown to so many others including cabinet ministers, various politicians, journalists and civil servants. It is recorded in a 1952 letter from Dean Inge, Bishop of Durham, to Alfred Noyes that in July the king himself showed him a document which Inge described as a copy, therefore not a manuscript diary and perhaps not a photograph.
Categorical proof that the king did not see manuscript diaries follows logically from the official claim that the typescripts were copied from early May to 24 June from manuscript diaries in police possession. That claim excludes the king receiving manuscript diaries in May. Therefore he saw either photographs or typescripts or both. The claim that the typescripts were true copies cannot be verified because there were neither impartial witnesses nor any independent witnesses to the material existence of manuscript diaries.
The inevitable conclusion is that the persons listed here – over fifty individuals including the Prime Minister and King George and many officials who could not be refused a viewing – never saw manuscript diaries in 1916; it therefore follows that no-one else saw such manuscripts in 1916.
Jeff allowed his cognitive model to be contaminated by personal ideological values which blinded him to the total absence of evidence for the existence of manuscript diaries in 1916. In attempting to defend the impossible – the authenticity of non-existent documents – he lost control and made multiple gaffes, errors which he tried to bury with chicanery, insinuation and speculation.
Recent books by Carroll and Philipps make no reference whatsoever to the undisputed fact that the typescripts were shown which simply highlights the critical sensitivity of the issue ‘manuscripts vs. typescripts’. In the end they too had to abandon common sense and resort to evasion, fake truth and propaganda to defend a state which defamed a man as author of invisible diaries, documents which no-one had seen because they did not exist.
© Paul R. Hyde. November, 2026
0 Comments